• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Offers
  • How tos
  • Listicles
  • Explainers
  • A-Z
  • Downloads
    • Adobe
    • DxO software
    • Capture One
    • Exposure X
    • ON1 software
    • Skylum
  • About

Life after Photoshop

  • Lightroom
  • Capture One
  • DxO PhotoLab
  • Nik Collection
  • Exposure X
  • ON1 Photo RAW
  • Aurora HDR

DxO PhotoLab vs Lightroom Classic – using PhotoLab for cataloguing

February 28, 2023 by Rod Lawton

PhotoLab vs Lightroom Classic for image organization is an interesting question. PhotoLab 6 offers better RAW processing and noise reduction than Lightroom Classic and more extensive local adjustment tools, but with the improvements to the PhotoLibrary in PhotoLab 6, can it also do the same job as an image cataloguing tool?

Photolab vs Lightroom
Are PhotoLab 6’s image organizing tools now good enough to tempt users away from Lightroom Classic? Image credit: Rod Lawton

It depends on your approach to image organization. Lightroom Classic works with catalogs, or databases. You have to import images into the catalog, and while you can move, rename and edit images within Lightroom and it will keep track of them perfectly well, if you move, edit or rename images outside of Lightroom, it will lose the link to the image file(s) until you manually reconned them or synchronize your folders. Lightroom does not offer a constant ‘live’ view of the images stored in your folders.

DxO PhotoLab 6 does. At hearts its PhotoLibrary window is a simple file browser, albeit with additional search and filtering tools. This is more likely to suit users who are happy to organize their images in folders and know where to look when they need them. It shows exactly what’s in your folders at any one time.

But this has its limits. What you also need is some way to separate out collections of images for a portfolio, for example, a web gallery, a client or just for your own interest. That’s why image organizing programs offer ‘Albums’ or ‘Collections’ – effectively, these are ‘virtual containers’ for photos perhaps stored in many different locations.

DxO PhotoLab has long offered ‘Projects’ in its PhotoLibrary panel, which are effectively albums under another name. However, the have traditionally been displayed as a single, linear list, which has limited their usefulness.

But PhotoLab 6 brought the ability to nest projects in a hierarchy, a feature easily overlooked amongst all the other improvements and additions, but one which completely changes the value of Projects. Now, you can arrange your images in PhotoLab Projects with all the hierarchical organization you get with Lightroom Collections.

This changes everything. From being a file browser with extra tools, the DxO PhotoLibrary has now become a Lightroom alternative with the benefits of live file browsing.

Photolab vs Lightroom
PhotoLab 6’s ability to arrange Projects in a hierarchy puts it on an equal footing with Lightroom Classic’s Collections. Image credit: Rod Lawton
Photolab vs Lightroom
PhotoLab 6’s search tools are very different to Lightroom Classic’s. Instead of in-depth drill-down metadata searches, it offers a simple pop-up Search box with search options that ‘autofill’ as you type, from image metadata to keywords. Image credit: Rod Lawton
Photolab vs Lightroom
Even in PhotoLab’s Customise (edit) mode, you still get a thumbnail browser and filtering options for color labels, star ratings and more. Image credit: Rod Lawton

DxO PhotoLab vs Lightroom Classic for organizing images

  • Folders: The key difference here is that Lightroom does not show a ‘live’ view of folder contents. For people who like to use folders as their primary organizational tool, PhotoLab is better because it will update to show any changes made elsewhere.
  • Albums/Projects: They are much the same. Both can organize images in a hierarchical system to produce any kind of organizational structure you like.
  • Smart Albums: Lightroom Classic has this very useful tool, but PhotoLab 6 does not. It does have a quick drop-down ‘autofill’ search tool which is quick and effective, though it can’t display more than 1000 matches at a time, annoyingly.
  • Searching/filtering: Lightroom Classic has the best tools if you really want to drill down into the details, but PhotoLab 6 has a quick and dirty search bar which can get you there just as effectively. The only issue is that there’s some vagueness over where PhotoLab is searching and which folders it has indexed in its internal database.

DxO PhotoLab vs Lightroom Classic: conclusions

Which one is best for editing is a separate argument. DxO’s RAW processing is better and its local adjustments are more precise; Lightroom has quick-access profiles and presets and AI subject masking.

For organizing images, it’s an interesting question. If your system is based mainly around folders but you also use albums/projects for specific, well, projects, then PhotoLab 6 may actually prove more effective for you than Lightroom Classic.

But if your organizational system is based around searches and filters and you don’t mind a ‘closed’ catalog system, then Lightroom Classic is rather more powerful.

Perhaps the point is, though, that PhotoLab 6’s image organizing tools are now good enough to offer a serious alternative to Lightroom’s. They are not as powerful, but they are quick and effective, and could be enough to tempt users into making the switch.

If you use PhotoLab 6 already, do take a proper look at the Project and Search tools. They didn’t start out very powerful, but they have come a long way.

If you haven’t tried PhotoLab 6 yet, use the link below to download a 30-day trial. That’s plenty of time to try out its features and make a decision.

  • Cataloguing software explained
  • Referenced vs managed files in cataloguing software: what’s the difference?
  • DxO PhotoLab vs Lightroom vs Capture One – which is best for RAW files?
  • Lightroom vs Lightroom Classic: same name, very different workflow

DxO software downloads and pricing*

DxO PhotoLab 6 Elite: regular price $219/£199
DxO ViewPoint 4: regular price $99/£89
DxO FilmPack 6 Elite: regular price $139/£129
DxO PureRAW 3: regular price $129/£115
DxO Nik Collection 5: regular price $149/£135

• 30 day trials are available for each product and bundle deals are available.

*Check for the latest offers at the DxO store

DxO store

Related

Filed Under: Featured, PhotoLab, WorkflowTagged With: Album, Browser (photos), Cataloguing software, Collection, Lightroom Classic (Adobe), PhotoLab (DxO)

Life after Photoshop is owned and run by photographer and journalist Rod Lawton. Rod has been a photography journalist for nearly 40 years, starting out in film (obviously) but then migrating to digital. He has worked as a freelance journalist, technique editor and channel editor, and is now Group Reviews Editor on Digital Camera World. Life after Photoshop is a personal project started in 2013.

Primary Sidebar

Subscribe to this site

Enter your email address to subscribe to Life after Photoshop and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Adobe Lightroom: what is it, where do you get it, what does it cost?

Adobe Lightroom is not one program but three. You could … [Read More...] about Adobe Lightroom: what is it, where do you get it, what does it cost?

The best photo editing software for organizing, editing, RAW and effects

Choosing the best image editing software used to be easy. … [Read More...] about The best photo editing software for organizing, editing, RAW and effects

Layers explained

Layers explained: what they do and how to use them

Layers are a central part of many photo editing processes, … [Read More...] about Layers explained: what they do and how to use them

BAN adjustments… Basic And Necessary image corrections to do first

Photo editing software does two quite different jobs. It can … [Read More...] about BAN adjustments… Basic And Necessary image corrections to do first

More Posts from this Category

Mission statement

Life after Photoshop is not anti-Photoshop or anti-subscriptions. It exists to showcase the many Photoshop alternatives that do more, go further, or offer more creative inspiration to photographers.

Affiliate links

Life after Photoshop is funded by affiliate links and may be paid a commission for downloads. This does not affect the price you pay, the ratings in reviews or the software selected for review.

Contact

Email lifeafterphotoshop@gmail.com

Copyright © 2023 Life after Photoshop · News Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in