• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Offers
  • How tos
  • Listicles
  • Explainers
  • A-Z
  • Downloads
    • Adobe
    • DxO software
    • Capture One
    • Exposure X
    • ON1 software
    • Skylum
  • About

Life after Photoshop

  • Lightroom
  • Capture One
  • DxO PhotoLab
  • Nik Collection
  • Exposure X
  • ON1 Photo RAW
  • Aurora HDR

Is luminance masking all it’s cracked up to be? I’m not convinced

April 25, 2022 by Life after Photoshop

The perfect candidate for luminance masking, you would think. I wanted a graduated filter effect over the bright sky that didn’t darken the darker cathedral below. Hmm… some hope.
Well, I got the result I wanted, but not with a luminance mask.

Luminance masking is a special masking mode that works on the brightness of different parts of the image. Basically, you can set a threshold where areas that are lighter (or darker) than your chosen value will not be affected by your adjustments.

One good example is where you want to use a graduated mask to darken a sky in an outdoor shot but there’s a tall building sticking up into the sky too.

Normally, this building would also be darkened by your graduated effect, and while you can get away with that up to a point with careful positioning and toned-down adjustments, it’s obviously not ideal.

So here’s the thing. Maybe it’s just me, or the kinds of images I work on, but out of all the (many) times I’ve used luminance masking to try to refine and restrict a mask to specific areas, I’d say it achieves a useful result maybe one time in five.

What you really need is a mask that affects the sky but shields the building, and that’s what – potentially – luminance mask can do. You can use the difference in brightness between the building and the sky to protect it from your sky adjustment.

It’s probably easiest to explain this with an example – and also to show the limitations of luminance masks. It’s not something you’re doing wrong, simply a limitation in what they can do.

This is a shot of the extraordinary Hallgrímskirkja cathedral in Reykjavík on an icy February afternoon. That sky does not look as intense as it did in real life, and I want to add some darkness and drama without affecting the cathedral, which is dark enough already.

1. Adding a graduated filter effect

Luminance mask

So here’s a ‘straight’ sky adjustment using a graduated mask and some curves adjustments. The sky is fine, but the cathedral tower is a bit of a disaster and makes my adjustment look obvious and clumsy.

2. Adding a luminance mask

Luminance mask

What I need to do is add a ‘luminance mask’ to the gradient mask so that my adjustments apply only to the sky, which is lighter, and not the cathedral, which is darker.

I’m working in Capture One, which lets you adjust the ‘luma range’ for any mask (it’s a slightly different term for the same thing). Other programs have their own versions. In the latest versions of Lightroom you would need to ‘intersect’ your mask with a luminance range.

The names and controls are different but the principle is the same. I have a black-to-white bar with sliders for setting the black/dark cutoff point and the white/light cutoff point. Capture One offers a pair of markers for setting the blend points, as does Lightroom (if you alt-drag the markers).

3. Shielding the dark tones

Luminance mask

First, I’ll enable the mask overlay so that you can see what’s happening more clearly. At the moment the mask covers the building as well as the sky, but if I drag the left-most marker to the right, it progressively shields the darker tones in the picture and you can see the mask overlay has disappeared from the cathedral tower.

4. So what’s the problem?

Well, you’ll see it’s also disappeared from the top right corner of the sky. It turns out that this is as dark as some of the tones in the tower, and if I move the slider to shield the tower completely, some of the sky is affected too – and if I drag the slider back to keep the sky fully masked, too much of the tower is affected.

Luminance mask

This is not because I haven’t used the controls with enough precision or care, it’s simply because the sky tones are not fully separated from those in the tower – there is too much overlap.

This is the fundamental weakness of luminance masking; it can only work when the conditions are right. I generally find that’s not very often.

5. Do the feathering/blending sliders help?

Sometimes, but not here. These are designed to smooth out abrupt tonal transitions created by your luminance mask. The trouble is, they won’t stop this cathedral tower being darkened, they will only help disguise the areas where it’s happened.

6. Swapping to the right tool for the job

Sometimes the masking tool you actually need isn’t the one you think. This image looked a prime candidate for a gradient/luminance mask to darken the sky alone. In fact, the solution was to select the building, which let me tweak the tones for this first, then invert the mask so that it applied to the sky, and enhance it that way. That proved both quicker and more effective than endless fiddling with a luminance mask.

So here’s the thing. Maybe it’s just me, or the kinds of images I work on, but out of all the (many) times I’ve used luminance masking to try to refine and restrict a mask to specific areas, I’d say it achieves a useful result maybe one time in five.

Read more:

  • Selections and masks: what do they do, what’s the difference?
  • The Lightroom Select Subject mask tool and how it works
  • Five quick masking tips to save time and get better results
  • Use Color Efex Pro control points to mask your graduated filters

Related

Filed Under: Featured, Tutorials

Life after Photoshop is owned and run by photographer and journalist Rod Lawton. Rod has been a photography journalist for nearly 40 years, starting out in film (obviously) but then migrating to digital. He has worked as a freelance journalist, technique editor and channel editor, and is now Group Reviews Editor on Digital Camera World. Life after Photoshop is a personal project started in 2013.

Primary Sidebar

Subscribe to this site

Enter your email address to subscribe to Life after Photoshop and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Adobe Lightroom: what is it, where do you get it, what does it cost?

Adobe Lightroom is not one program but three. You could … [Read More...] about Adobe Lightroom: what is it, where do you get it, what does it cost?

The best photo editing software for organizing, editing, RAW and effects

Choosing the best image editing software used to be easy. … [Read More...] about The best photo editing software for organizing, editing, RAW and effects

Layers explained

Layers explained: what they do and how to use them

Layers are a central part of many photo editing processes, … [Read More...] about Layers explained: what they do and how to use them

BAN adjustments… Basic And Necessary image corrections to do first

Photo editing software does two quite different jobs. It can … [Read More...] about BAN adjustments… Basic And Necessary image corrections to do first

More Posts from this Category

Mission statement

Life after Photoshop is not anti-Photoshop or anti-subscriptions. It exists to showcase the many Photoshop alternatives that do more, go further, or offer more creative inspiration to photographers.

Affiliate links

Life after Photoshop is funded by affiliate links and may be paid a commission for downloads. This does not affect the price you pay, the ratings in reviews or the software selected for review.

Contact

Email lifeafterphotoshop@gmail.com

Copyright © 2023 Life after Photoshop · News Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in